Sweetie Pies LLC

Information may not be reliable

Welcome to

Pies, Chocolate, Coffee, Gifts and Gab

We make pies the old fashioned way!
Located in picturesque Door County, Wisconsin, south of Fish Creek , Sweetie Pies offers a scrumptious selection of handmade pies.
Our customers say nobody makes them better, except maybe Grandma!

Our cozy little shop is part of the Settlement Shops right next to
Fish Creek's popular Settlement Courtyard Inn (Find Us.)
Started by Susan Croissant in 1995, it is now run by the Lea and Mazurek families, along with a great crew .
In addition to pies of assorted flavors and sizes, and our ever popular crust cookies, we offer an assortment of handmade chocolates.
Beerntsen's Chocolates are from a treasured, old-fashioned chocolate shop in Manitowoc and Green Bay. We are glad to feature them now!
And we have gifts too!! Ceramic ware, mugs, pie birds, T-shirts, to name but a few. There are locally made jams, jellies, syrups and dried fruits.
We also offer classes on pie and chocolate making. Chicago and Milwaukee residents should check out our Road Trip info.
And everybody should check out Holiday Fun!
So come on in and take a little on-line tour. Click any pictures or places that look interesting - you might find some surprizes! Use the back button if you get lost!
Check out the recent announcements and see what's been happening!!

Sweetie Pies is open seven days a week, 9 to 5

Store hours: Summer (Memorial to Labor Day) 9 to 5 seven days a week! Fall Hours (till Mid Nov): 10 to 4 daily Winter 10 to 4 Saturday, Sunday & Monday (some variation in between)

Navigating suggestion: little pie ladies to the left will bring you back here,
other symbols to the right will bring you back to that section.
877-868-2744 (toll free) or 920-868-2743 in Door County e-mail: sweetiepieshop@dcwis.com PO Box 196 - Fish Creek - Wisconsin - 54212